Banking mistake leaves man richer by over Rs 1 lakh — & in jail 2 years later

The Indian Express | 2 months ago | 28-03-2023 | 12:45 pm

Banking mistake leaves man richer by over Rs 1 lakh — & in jail 2 years later

A bank account with over Rs 1 lakh that was ‘mistakenly’ linked to his Aadhaar number two years ago has cost Jeetrai Samant his freedom.The 42-year-old beedi worker, from Jharkhand’s West Singhbhum district, has been arrested by the state police for allegedly withdrawing the money that belonged to a woman, whose bank account was linked to his Aadhaar number erroneously.Samant came to know of the money two years ago, as Covid cast its shadow across the nation, through a Common Service Centre. The centres serve as access points for delivery of essential public services, welfare schemes, etc in rural and remote areas of the country. According to sources familiar with the probe, the CSC also had a bank representative to help withdraw money that a beneficiary might have in his or her account.But the law caught up with Samant last September, when the manager of Jharkhand Rajya Gramin Bank received a complaint from an account holder named Shrimati Laguri regarding money disappearing from her account. The manager wrote to the authorities and, on discovering the error that had taken place, asked Samant to return the money. Since he was unable to do so, an FIR was lodged against him in October under IPC section 406 (criminal breach of trust) and 420 (cheating) in the district’s Muffasil police station.Superintendent of Police Ashutosh Shekhar told The Indian Express: “Samant was arrested on March 24. There was a mistake and his Aadhaar got linked to someone else’s account, but he did not return the amount. He allegedly paid a bribe at the CSC point so no one else would get to know. (When police issued a notice about the issue) he wrote a letter to us saying he believed Prime Minister Narendra Modi had sent him money.”Bank manager Manish Kumar told The Indian Express: “Earlier, Bank of India used to sponsor the Gramin Bank, and now SBI does it. So the entire data was merged with SBI in April 2019, and it was during this process that Samant’s Aadhaar number got accidentally linked with someone else’s bank account. The woman did not complain earlier, else we could have stopped it.” He said it was “difficult” to pin blame on a single bank official.A UIDAI official, requesting anonymity, said: “This is clearly the bank’s mistake. The UIDAI has no role in it.”From October to March, Samant received three notices to appear before the police under CrPC section 41 A, under which police can arrest a person without a warrant in case he fails to appear before the court or the police since he is an accused.The Indian Express had spoken to Samant in December, before his arrest. At the time, he claimed: “During the first lockdown, everyone in the village was checking the amount in their Aadhaar-linked account numbers as it was announced that people would receive something. I put my thumb on the reading machine and it showed a balance as Rs 1,12,000. I rushed to the Gramin Bank, but could not find any money having been credited there. When I asked them about it, they told me the government would have sent the amount.”Police have claimed he withdrew Rs 2 lakh.Samant, a father of six children, said he kept withdrawing the money during the lockdown since he was in financial distress and believed it had come from the government.In response to one of the police notices, Samant had written to Superintendent of Police, Chaibasa, Ashutosh Shekhar in December. He claimed: “During the lockdown, there was a talk in the village that the Modi government is giving money in the account. My Aadhaar-based account showed Rs 1 lakh. The bank manager said I could withdraw the money. Now a case has been registered against me. I am not at fault. Without my knowledge, my Aadhaar was linked to someone else’s bank account. For the last two years, the bank did not even inform me.”Sub-inspector Ratu Oraon of Pandrasali observation point told The Indian Express: “After receiving the first notice, Samant did come to the police station, but he did not commit to returning the amount. Obviously there was a mistake when his Aadhaar got linked with Shrimati Laguri’s account number, but it was his moral responsibility not to withdraw the amount.”Asked why the arrest was not made earlier, Oraon said: “This was not an urgent case.”He added that Samant’s account originally had only Rs 650, but he kept withdrawing amounts ranging between Rs 500 and Rs 5,000. “Even during withdrawals, the name of the account holder must have appeared, but he chose to ignore that.”

Google Follow Image

Similar News

Mumbai murder: She was ‘like daughter’, says man accused of cutting partner into pieces
The Indian Express | 18 hours ago | 09-06-2023 | 12:45 pm
The Indian Express
18 hours ago | 09-06-2023 | 12:45 pm

The man accused of killing his alleged live-in partner in their flat in Geeta Nagar area of Mira Road, near Mumbai, and allegedly chopping the body into innumerable pieces, has told police during interrogation that he is HIV-positive and had never had physical relationship with Vaidya, as she was “like his daughter”, a senior police officer told The Indian Express.The officer said that accused Manoj Ramesh Sane, 56, who was arrested on Thursday, has claimed that Saraswati Vaidya, 32, died by suicide on June 3. Fearing that he would be booked in the case, he allegedly tried to dispose of the body, and told police that he planned to end his life thereafter, the officer said.The officer, who visited the spot on Wednesday night, after the death came to light, said details of Sane’s claims during interrogation are being verified.After cutting the body into small parts with an electric tree cutter, Sane allegedly boiled parts of it in a pressure cooker and roasted them on gas to dump them easily, police said. He had allegedly kept the pieces in a bucket, tub, cooker and other vessels in the kitchen, and cut them so small that police could not even count them, an officer said.Police have invoked IPC Sections 302 (murder) and 201 (destruction of evidence) in the FIR. “He was produced in a Thane court and has been remanded in police custody until June 16,” DCP Jayant Bajbale, zone-1, Mira-Bhayander Vasai Virar police, said.“During preliminary inquiry, Sane told police that in 2008 he discovered that he was HIV positive,” the senior officer said. “Since then, he has been on medication. He said that he suspects he contracted the disease due to use of infected blood during his treatment a long time ago, after he had met with an accident.”According to Sane’s confession to police, Vaidya was very possessive in nature and suspected that he was being unfaithful to her whenever he returned home late, the officer said. She was planning to appear for Class 10 SSC exams and Sane was teaching her math, the officer said, quoting from his admission during interrogation.The officer said they found a board on one of the walls of the seventh-floor flat, with math equations scribbled on it.Sane told police that he saw Vaidya lying on the floor of their flat on June 3 morning, froth coming out of her mouth. He checked her pulse and found her dead, he told police. Fearing action against him, Sane reportedly told police, he decided to get rid of the body.Sane has told police that he has an Industrial Training Institute certificate but has been working at a PDS shop for 10 years as he did not get a decent job. The body parts collected from the kitchen have been sent to Sir JJ Hospital for forensic analysis, DCP Bajbale said.Police are taking the help of medical experts and trying to ascertain which parts of the body are missing. They have seized an electric cutter. Police suspect the crime took place earlier and emerged on Wednesday, when neighbours reported foul smell from the couple’s flat. After police were informed, they broke open the door to gain entry into the flat and found the woman’s body, chopped into pieces, in the kitchen. Unaware of police presence, Sane returned home in the evening. He was nabbed as he tried to escape, an officer said.A senior officer said when the accused was being questioned, he showed no remorse.

Mumbai murder: She was ‘like daughter’, says man accused of cutting partner into pieces
In Uttarkashi, ‘love jihad’ row weighs heavy on some shopkeepers, residents
The Indian Express | 18 hours ago | 09-06-2023 | 12:45 pm
The Indian Express
18 hours ago | 09-06-2023 | 12:45 pm

Zahid Malik came to Purola town in Uttarakhand’s Uttarkashi district over 30 years ago, and has been running a readymade garments shop for 18 years. He had also joined the BJP six years ago. However, on Wednesday night, he had packed everything up and loaded it into a truck as he got ready to shut the shop for good.He is one of at least seven Muslim shop owners in Purola market to permanently close their shops and leave the town in the past two-three days.Zahid’s elder brother, Abdul Wahid, had moved to Purola much before Zahid. The tailoring shop that Abdul ran for more than three decades has been managed by his son, Shahnawaz, ever since Abdul’s death a few years ago. Now, Shahnawaz is also considering leaving town.Tensions in the Purola area erupted on May 26 after two men were allegedly found with a minor girl by some local residents. One of the two men was Muslim, leading to allegations of “love jihad”.Police identified the two men as Ubaid Khan (24) and Jitendra Saini (23), who were booked under sections 363 (kidnapping) and 366A (procuration of minor girl) of the IPC, as well as under the POCSO Act. They are currently in judicial custody.Uttarkashi, Uttarakhand: Muslim owned shops forcibly closed by Hindutva outfits! Posters have come up asking Muslim traders to vacate their shops before a Panchayat for “targeting Hindu women” to be held on June 15! Some Muslim shopkeepers have left Uttarkashi & came to Dehradun! pic.twitter.com/FQ6vYJD0bL— Muslim Spaces (@MuslimSpaces) June 6, 2023An officer familiar with the investigation said, “The girl did not know these people… There is no love jihad angle. We can call it love jihad only if the girl and boys knew each other, or the guy introduced himself as someone else, or they already had a friendship. But that is not the case here.”The day after the incident, protest rallies were organised by right-wing groups, the local Vyapar Mandal (trade union), and some residents. They demanded strict action against the accused and called for a stringent verification process of “outsiders” who come to the town.Posters also came up threatening Muslim traders with consequences if they did not shut down their shops.There are around 35-40 shops run by Muslims in Purola, and all have been shut for the past 12 days.The district administration have meanwhile formed joint teams of revenue and police officials to verify the antecedents of those coming from outside.“There are around five-six (Muslim) families living here for decades, including ours, and they, too, are being targeted now. They are using social media to threaten us. We have also been removed from the WhatsApp group of the Vyapar Mandal. Instead of giving us security, the PAC (Provincial Armed Constabulary) jawans deployed here are asking us not to leave our houses,” said Mohammad Ashraf (41), who runs a garment shop in the area. Ashraf is one of the few members of the community to own a house in Purola.“My family came to Purola in 1978 from Bijnor. Our shop was one of the first few in the area. Three generations of my family lived here, but we have never seen anything like this before… I was born here. I studied in the local Saraswati Shishu Mandir. Most of my friends here are Hindus. We cannot leave this place,” he said.Those who have already left include three traders of toys and crockery, two who were running garments shops, one car wash owner, and one mobile repair shop owner.Having shut down his garment shop, Zahid said he would leave the BJP. He claimed that he was the Uttarkashi district president of the BJP’s minority wing, but the party’s district president Satendra Rana denied this, saying that post was currently vacant and that Zahid had once been a district general secretary.On his decision to shut his business in Purola, Zahid said, “There was a big rally on May 28, during which some people vandalised the hoardings and flex boards of shops owned by Muslims. At that time, I came to Dehradun. We thought we would wait a few days until the situation gets normal. But then, there was another rally in Badkot. Four days ago, we decided to leave Purola.”He said he would look for a shop to rent in Dehradun’s Vikas Nagar area.Local resident Abhishek Semwal, a BJP member, said several Muslim families had been living in the area for decades, but that “problems” started when “new people started coming and opening shops”.Semwal and others, like BJP office bearer Pawan Nautiyal, alleged that such “outsiders” were involved in illegal activities.Meanwhile, Purola sub-divisional magistrate Devanand Sharma Thursday held a Peace Committee Meeting with local public representatives, influential members of society, and local members of the Muslim community. He said that the situation was under control.On Friday, another meeting will be held with local residents to decide the future course of action.Brij Mohan Chauhan, president of the Purola Vyapar Mandal, said: “It is expected that we will ask the administration to make sure that those coming from outside present a character certificate from their local police station. Those already living here for several decades will be allowed to stay here. We will give them a date when they can open their shops.”

In Uttarkashi, ‘love jihad’ row weighs heavy on some shopkeepers, residents
International referee speaks: ‘I saw Brij Bhushan standing next to her, she freed herself... something wrong happened to her’
The Indian Express | 18 hours ago | 09-06-2023 | 12:45 pm
The Indian Express
18 hours ago | 09-06-2023 | 12:45 pm

In the FIR filed by six adult wrestlers detailing several incidents of alleged sexual harassment by Wrestling Federation of India president Brij Bhushan Sharan Singh, one complainant said that in March last year, as the team posed for a photo at the end of the trials in Lucknow for the Asian Championships, he “placed his hands on my buttocks” following which she tried to move away.Jagbir Singh, an international wrestling referee since 2007, who was standing a few feet away from Brij Bhushan and the complainant, has corroborated the wrestler’s allegations in his testimony to the Delhi Police. Speaking to The Indian Express, Jagbir Singh referred to the photo and said that Delhi police had asked him about it.Jagbir is among the over 125 potential witnesses, across four states, who are part of the police probe that is expected, as per Union Sports Minister Anurag Thakur’s statement Wednesday, to be wrapped up June 15.An Olympian, a Commonwealth Games gold medallist, an international referee and a state-level coach have corroborated the allegations of at least three female wrestlers, The Indian Express has reported.“I saw him (Brij Bhushan) standing next to her. She freed herself, pushed away, mumbled and moved away. She was standing next to the president, but then came to the front. I saw how this woman wrestler was reacting and she was uncomfortable. Uske saath kuchh galat hua (Something wrong happened to her). I didn’t see him doing the act but uske haath pair khoob chalte the, idhar aa ja. Idhar khadi ho ja (He used to keep touching wrestlers saying come here, come and stand here). From her (complainant’s) behaviour, it was clear something was wrong that day (during the photo session),” Jagbir said.According to the FIR, Singh forcibly held her by the shoulder before she could break free and move to the front row for the photograph.“Since I was one of the tallest wrestlers, I was supposed to stand in the last row. While I was standing in the last row and waiting for the other wrestlers to take their positions, the accused came and stood alongside me. To my shock and surprise, I suddenly felt a hand on my buttock. I immediately looked back and to my horror, the accused had placed his hands on my buttocks… I immediately tried to move away from that spot in order to protect myself from further inappropriate touching by the accused. However, when I tried moving away, I was forcibly held by my shoulder by the accused. Somehow, I managed to get free from the clutches of the accused. Since I could not have avoided getting the team photograph clicked, I decided to go and sit in the first row away from the accused,” the FIR states.The FIR adds that the woman wrestler was stunned by Singh’s “highly indecent” and “objectionable” action which was without her consent.Jagbir is the second witness this paper has spoken to, the other being 2010 CWG gold medallist Anita. Both have corroborated claims made by at least two wrestlers.Anita said that the complainant had called her from a tournament abroad to “share” the incident where Brij Bhushan had allegedly called her to his room and “forcibly” hugged her. The complainant cried when narrating her ordeal to Anita, after returning to the national camp in Patiala. In her complaint, she has said that she was “traumatised” because of the “forcible hug” on the night of her gold-medal victory.In the two FIRs filed by Delhi Police, based on complaints of seven woman wrestlers, including a minor, there have been at least two instances of the WFI chief demanding “sexual favours” in lieu of professional assistance; close to 15 incidents of sexual harassment that include 10 episodes of inappropriate touching, molestation that includes running hands over breasts, touching the navel; and several instances of intimidation, including stalking.On Wednesday, there was a breakthrough in the protracted standoff between the protesting wrestlers and the Government. The wrestlers, Olympic medallists Bajrang Punia and Sakshi Malik, who met Thakur, agreed to pause their protest until June 15. This is the date by which the Delhi Police will file a chargesheet, Thakur said.

International referee speaks: ‘I saw Brij Bhushan standing next to her, she freed herself... something wrong happened to her’
Inflation is down – but RBI remains vigilantPremium Story
The Indian Express | 18 hours ago | 09-06-2023 | 12:45 pm
The Indian Express
18 hours ago | 09-06-2023 | 12:45 pm

The Monetary Policy Committee of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has preferred to stand put than surprise the way it did in April. That is par for the course. The inflation print for the last two months seems to indicate that the peak has been passed: The wholesale price index (WPI) inflation fell to -0.9 per cent in April from 1.3 per cent in March, while the consumer price index (CPI) inflation declined to 4.7 per cent from 5.7 per cent. We expect the pause to continue through 2023.The RBI has communicated that its fight against inflation is not over till it is aligned with its target of 4 per cent on a durable basis. This implies it will not be in a hurry to cut rates. We foresee a rate cut only in January-March 2024.While a likely end of the rate hike cycle in advanced countries over the next couple of months will help, softening domestic inflation is swaying Mint Road. Additionally, the withdrawal of Rs 2,000 bank notes, 50 per cent of which have been returned, is expected to inject liquidity into the system.Meanwhile in the US, tightening financial conditions, amid the banking stress, helped the Federal Reserve (Fed) by creating a downside to growth and inflation. The enduring gap between Fed’s communication and market expectation is narrowing and the markets now see the Fed funds rate at around 5 per cent at the end of the year compared with below 4 per cent a couple of months back. Fed’s mid-June rate decision will be a close call. That said, a “higher for longer” scenario looks more likely in the US, given above target inflation and the strength of economic activity there.In Europe, however, core inflation has been quite sticky, and the European Central Bank is likely to continue raising rates. Interestingly, the Bank of Canada and the Reserve Bank of Australia raised interest rates in June. On the other hand, most emerging markets have seen the peak of the rate hiking cycle.In India, a sharper-than-anticipated decline in inflation in March and April was driven by base effect and a correction in commodity prices, which had spiked due to the Russia-Ukraine conflict last year, creating a favourable statistical base effect. Although the favourable base effect will fade over the next few months, we expect consumer inflation to average 5 per cent this fiscal as compared to 6.7 per cent last fiscal.Normal monsoons are important for a durable decline in cereal inflation, which is currently in double digits and has a high weight in consumer prices. In May, the India Meteorological Department reiterated its normal monsoon forecast. So, assuming a normal monsoon, we expect food inflation to soften.That said, what matters for agriculture and food inflation is not just the amount of rainfall, but also its distribution over time and geography. Clarity on this aspect will emerge with the progress of the monsoon.It would be the fifth successive normal monsoon — if it does turn out to be one. That is a rarity. With climate change at play, monsoons can always throw a curveball. Plus, the Australian Bureau of Meteorology recently elevated the El Nino watch to the “alert” category, indicating a 70 per cent chance of El Nino this year. Fingers crossed, therefore.Fuel inflation is already heading down and will come down further as global crude prices will be lower compared with last fiscal. We expect the per-barrel brent price at $80-85 this fiscal year compared to $95 in the previous one.Core inflation, obtained by excluding fuel and food from the overall CPI basket, has been the sticker part of inflation, not only in the last fiscal but also in the past. Slowing domestic demand and lower input prices will help tame it a bit.Another interesting feature of inflation dynamics is the goods versus services inflation. Goods inflation has corrected more than services inflation. Historically, service inflation has been higher than goods inflation. During the pandemic, due to reduced demand for services, its inflation stayed lower than goods inflation, which had spiked due to the supply shock amid continued demand for manufacturing products. That is correcting.Demand for services such as airlines and hospitality has turned fast and furious with the withdrawal of Covid-induced restrictions and this is pushing up their prices. Concomitantly, the correction of commodity prices has dragged WPI into deflation territory and will help soften consumer price inflation with a lag.For 2023-24, RBI has maintained its growth forecast of 6.5 per cent and cut its inflation forecast. Growth for 2022-23 was revised up by the National Statistical Office recently to 7.2 per cent from 7 per cent. The momentum for the first quarter of the current fiscal so far is quite healthy, as expected by the RBI, which has forecast a 8 per cent growth for the quarter.As per S&P Global’s Purchasing Manager Index (PMI), both manufacturing and services remained robust in the first two months of this quarter. Between April and May, the manufacturing PMI rose from 57.2 to 58.7, while for services, it was above 60 in both months.The numbers for 2022-23 show consumption and investment activity were quite robust, outpacing overall GDP growth. While investment remained strong for all four quarters of last year, private consumption slowed down towards the second half. We expect investment momentum to continue this fiscal and private consumption to be a tad slower compared to last year.On the whole, we expect growth to slow to 6 per cent this fiscal as global economic activity decelerates in the second half of 2023 — after a better-than-anticipated showing in the past few months — and the lagged impact repo rate hikes show up. Consequently, merchandise exports, which have been already slipping, will decline more as growth in the West, India’s major export market, unravels. On the other hand, China is growing but that does not help much — they account for less than 5 per cent of our total exports.Housing and auto loans have already risen past pre-pandemic levels and given that some transmission of the rate hikes is yet to play out, activity would moderate down the road. With consumer inflation in the first quarter set to print lower than its forecast of 5.1 per cent, there is little surprise the RBI cut the inflation forecast to 5.1 per cent from 5.2 per cent for the full fiscal. As for agriculture output and prices, the eyes are riveted on the monsoon.The writer is Chief Economist, CRISIL

Inflation is down – but RBI remains vigilantPremium Story